Tour Scotland
Home Page


Click Here for: Scottish Cooking or Recipes
Shopping from USA or Shopping from UK
Small Group Tours Of Scotland



The Bonny Earl

On the seashore below the ancient castle of Donibristle the young Earl of Moray - the Bonny Earl - was slain. He was a handsome youth. And vain of his good looks. Even as he died he taunted his slayer with spoiling a fairer face than his own. The chroniclers of the day described him as "the lustiest youth", and "a comelie personage, strong of body".

He was a braw gallant
And he rid at the ring,
And the bonny Earl o' Moray,
Oh, he might hae been a king.

He was a braw gallant,
And he played at the gluve,
And the bonny Earl o' Moray,
Oh, he was the Queen's luve.

Yes, the ballad-mongers of the day who sang his beauty linked his name with that of King James's Queen. She thought him handsome, and in her husband's hearing she recklessly praised him " with too many epithets, as a proper and gallant man". That, and the fact that his name was dangerously linked with those of the King's known enemies, were enough to condemn him, and when, on 7th February, 1592, the Earl of Huntly left Holyrood on pretence of going to a horse-race at Leith, he actually was on his way to Donibristle and carried a mandate for Moray's arrest. Passage of all boats but Huntly's was stopped on the Queen's Ferry, and, with a posse of forty men, he arrived at Donibristle. Moray barred the door, but Huntly's men set fire to the castle, and Moray did not know "whether to come out and be slain, or remain and be burnt". His friend Dunbar went out first, hoping to be mistaken for Moray and allow him to escape in the confusion. And the ruse worked. Dunbar was attacked and died, but Moray escaped to the shore. Tradition has it that he escaped down a subterranean passage. Then he was discovered by a tragically ludicrous accident. A silken string on his hood had caught fire; the flame was seen and betrayed his where-abouts. Gordon of Buckie, one of Huntly's followers, struck him down and then forced Huntly to deliver the death blow with his dagger.

For this deed the King punished Huntly only lightly, and when, two days after the murder, the Earl's mother, Lady Doune, brought the corpses of her son and Dunbar to Holyrood to present them to the King, James went out hunting.

Return To Even More Scottish Anecdotes