A flurry of
books marked the last half-dozen years of his life. Not everyone
realised there were two authors producing a stream of material;
there was a Scottish writer of great talent who called himself
"Lewis Grassic Gibbon", a thin disguise of his mother's
maiden name; there was a professional journalist and critic called
"J. Leslie Mitchell" who kept an independent output
of material just as professional, just as well written, but drawn
from very different sources.
Mitchell believed
wholeheartedly in the diffusionist theory that civilisation was
a blight slowly strangling the native goodness and ability of
human kind, the Depression simply the last gasp of a corrupt system,
and that revolution and the shaking-off of Church and State, Government
and class was the only way forward. A Marxist and an anarchist,
Mitchell would have welcomed revolution, though as a writer he
also faced a plangent nostalgia for a Scotland which he had known
in youth, and watched destroyed by the First World War which changed
the Mearns beyond recognition.
The themes
of his work are clearly set. On the one hand, he produced autobiographical
writing which celebrated that Scotland, Stained radiance, The
Thirteenth disciple, an unfinished novel The Speak of the Mearns
and - unforgettably - Sunset song in which he shows his thinly-disguised
autobiographical self (cleverly re-cast as a female protagonist,
Chris, who run through the trilogy as a binding thread) watching
the sunset of an age, while singing its beauty as well as the
harshness of the tough farming conditions of his childhood experience.
In the first
part of the trilogy we read about the author's childhood years,
small farms, tight communities, harvest, spring, weddings, funerals
- a Scotland easy to love, but never veering to kailyard or sentiment,
since the other side is never far away, grinding repetitive work,
gossip, spite. But the sunset comes with War, with the killing-off
of the finest in the community, the dreadful stripping of the
trees without which the old farming is effectively killed off.
The rest of
the trilogy carries the story forward, away from nostalgia and
times past, to a Scotland of here and now, industrial Scotland,
smallish towns, finally the city (Aberdeen) in the Depression
years, grey, hopeless, sometimes violent - a diffusionist's nightmare
of the human spirit ground down. But it is a brave modern Scottish
classic, turning away from easy temptations to romanticise Scotland,
and facing up to the consequences of change. It was published
in 1934, just before the author's death, and it was fully up to
date.
Oddly enough,
though much of the rest of his output was fantasy (highly successful
science fiction, Three go back and Gay Hunter) it was firmly up
to date too: Mitchell wrote about societies without the blight
of civilisation, trying to show that human beings had once been
free, could be again. Wonderfully successful short stories about
the Scottish countryside make the same point again and again.
Paradoxically, the author himself had to break free - to Welwyn
Garden City, in Hertfordshire - to gain the freedom to see Scotland
clearly. But when he did, he re-Created the past, and sharpened
the present, more successfully than any other writer of the century.
Part of the
success lies in the use of language, innovative and very much
open to first time readers. Without a strong covering of phonetic
Scots, Mitchell writes in what looks like effortless English,
though a lot of what is written can be read out aloud as Scots,
many of the words disguised as common English words, though recognisable
to a Scot for what they are. It is a non-threatening style, lyrical,
musical, and it has done much to explain the success of his work.
Television
brought him to a new audience of millions, in North America as
well as in Britain. He is widely taught in school and university.
His Scotland is bitter-sweet, a place where real people live,
and work, and die. It is not a Scotland of misty past, but a Scotland
of sharp-edged present, with a respect for the past which does
not sentimentalise or take refuge in a vanished countryside.
James Leslie
Mitchell was to have a short success. Republished in the USA,
he was rapidly growing in reputation when peritonitis carried
him off suddenly in early 1935, at the threshold of what seemed
likely to be a very successful career. His close friend Hugh MacDiarmid
co-operated with him in Scottish scene (1934), a jointly-authored
squib in which they lambasted what was wrong with their country.
In its savage attacks on people, institutions and cities (Mitchell
on Glasgow and Aberdeen is unforgettable) it is elegant, witty,
timely. It was a major loss to Scottish writing when Mitchell
died, and thirty years of eclipse were to follow before the recent
revival and - most important - republication which is again making
available one of Scotland's most important modern authors.